M.P. Botkin’s collection: sources and historiography
No. 1 (20) (2021), Forum
No. 1 (20) (2021)

M.P. Botkin’s collection: sources and historiography

Forum
УДК 7.074 DOI: https://doi.org/10.46748/ARTEURAS.2021.01.009
Published 2021-03-31
Elena Vyacheslavovna Bakaldina
Saint-Petersburg State Roerich Family Museum and Institute

eLibrary ID elenabakaldina@gmail.com

Abstract

Collection of the painter, collector and public figure M.P. Botkin (1839–1914) included objects from different eras and countries: ancient Egyptian, antique, Western European, Byzantine, Russian objects, as well as pictures of Russian and foreign artists. The article is the first comprehensive study of the collection with the involvement of a wide source base, as well as showing the directions for studying the collection items. Part of the collection has been identified and described, some items have become the subject of separate research, but the rest of the items need to be identified and attributed.

https://doi.org/10.46748/ARTEURAS.2021.01.009

References

  1. Ajnalov D.V. Jellinisticheskie osnovy vizantijskogo iskusstva: Issledovanie v oblasti istorii ranne-vizantantijskogo iskusstva [Hellenistic Foundations of Byzantine Art: A Study in the History of Early Byzantine Art]. St. Petersburg, I.N. Skorohodov Publ., 1900. IV, 229 p. (In Russian).
  2. Akinsha K.A. Vremja kollekcij. Universal'nye sobranija Rossii 60–80-h godov [Time of Collection. Universal collections of Russia 60–80s]. Tipologija russkogo realizma vtoroj poloviny XIX veka. Sbornik st. [Typology of Russian realism in the second half of the 19th century. Digest of articles]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1990, pp. 39–64. (In Russian).
  3. Goldovskiy G. et al. (comp.). Aleksandr Ivanov: katalog vystavki [Alexander Ivanov: catalog of exhibition]. St. Petersburg, Palace Editions, 2006. 167 p. (In Russian).
  4. Aleksandrova N. Russkij risunok XVIII – pervoj poloviny XIX veka [Russian Drawings 18th – first half of the 19th century]. Moscow, Krasnaja ploshhad' Publ., 2004, Book 2. 479 p. (In Russian).
  5. Aleksandrova N.A. Russkij risunok XVIII – pervoj poloviny XIX veka [Russian Drawings 18th – first half of the 19th century]. Moscow, Krasnaja ploshhad' Publ., 2004, Book 1. 479 p. (In Russian).
  6. Altaev Al. Pamjatnye vstrechi [Memorable meetings]. Moscow, Sovetskij pisatel' Publ., 1959. 412 p. (In Russian).
  7. Amiranashvili Sh.Ja. Istorija gruzinskogo iskusstva [History of Georgian art]. Moscow, Iskusstvo Publ., 1963. 463, 269 p. (In Russian).
  8. Androsov S. O. Ital'janskaja skul'ptura XIV–XVI vekov. Katalog kollekcii [Italian sculpture 14th – 16th centuries. Catalog of collection]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Publ., 2007. 206 p. (In Russian).
  9. Antichnaja koroplastika: Katalog vystavki [Antique Coroplastic: Catalog of exhibition]. Leningrad, Avrora Publ., 1976. 110 p. (In Russian).
  10. Kunina N. (comp.). Antichnoe steklo iz sobranija Jermitazha [Antique glass from the Hermitage collection]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Publ., ARS Publ., 1997. 339 p. (In Russian).
  11. Arsentjeva E.I., Gorskaja O.V. (comp.). Antichnye juvelirnye izdelija iz chastnyh sobranij. Kol'ca i perstni: katalog kollekcii [Antique jewelry from private collections. Rings and signet rings: collection catalog]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Publ., 2019. 194 p. (In Russian).
  12. Antonova V. I., Mneva N. E. Katalog drevnerusskoj zhivopisi. Opyt istoriko-hudozhestvennoj klassifikacii. XI – nachalo XVI veka [Catalog of Old Russian Painting. Experience of historical and artistic classification. 11th – early 16th century]. Moscow, Iskusstvo Publ., 1963. Vol. 1. 394 p. (In Russian).
  13. Arkhiv Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha [Archive of the State Hermitage], coll. 1, aids 5, No. 110. (In Russian).
  14. Arkhiv Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha [Archive of the State Hermitage], coll. 1, aids 5, No. 330. (In Russian).
  15. Arkhiv Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha [Archive of the State Hermitage], coll. 4, aids 1, No. 1490. (In Russian).
  16. Arkhiv Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha [Archive of the State Hermitage], coll. 4, aids 1, No. 1491. (In Russian).
  17. Arkhiv Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha [Archive of the State Hermitage], coll. 4, aids 3, No. 6. (In Russian).
  18. Arhiv sem'i Ehnden [Archives of the Enden family.]. Enden N.M. Dela davno minuvshih dnej [The affairs of days gone]. 1917–1921. 1950. (In Russian).
  19. Aukcion risunkov, akvarelej, farfora i hudozhestvennyh izdanij v pomeshhenii bjuro “Iskusstvo” 12 i 13 maja 1918 g. [Auction of drawings, watercolors, porcelain and art publications in the premises of the Bureau “Art” 12 and 13 May 1918 . Catalog]. Petrograd, Lavrov i K° Publ.,1918. 20 p. (In Russian).
  20. Asheshova A.N. Raspylennaya kollektsiya: o sovremennom mestonakhozhdenii ehmalei iz kollektsii M.P. Botkina [Dispersed collection: about the modern location of enamels from the collection of M.P. Botkin] Juvelirnoe iskusstvo i material'naja kul'tura [Jewelry and material culture]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Publ., 2015, pp. 5–9. (In Russian).
  21. Bakaldina E.V. Sobranie M.P. Botkina: chastnaja kollekcija ili muzej [Collection of M.P. Botkin: private collection or museum]. Muzej. Pamjatnik. Nasledie — Museum. Monument. Heritage, 2020, No. 1 (7), pp. 46–56. (In Russian).
  22. Bakaldina E.V. Sud'ba chasti sobranija M.P. Botkina, ostavshejsja v ego osobnjake posle revoljucii [The fate of a part of M.P. Botkin, who remained in his house after the revolution]. M.P. Botkin i ego kollekcija [M.P. Botkin and his collection]. (Prescript). (In Russian).
  23. Belogolovyj N.A. Vospominanija i drugie stat'i [Memories and other articles]. Moscow, K.F. Aleksandrov Publ., 1897. XXXII, XII, 654 p. (In Russian).
  24. Benua A.N., Jaremich S.P. Sobranie Mihaila Petrovicha Botkina [Collection of Mikhail Petrovich Botkin]. Hudozhestvennye sokrovishha Rossii — Artistic treasures of Russia, 1902, No. 2, pp. 23–66, Applications 13–36. (In Russian).
  25. Beruchashvili N.L. Ob istorii peregorodchatykh ehmalei M.P. Botkina v Gosudarstvennom muzee iskusstv Gruzii [About the history of cloisonn? enamels M.P. Botkin at the State Museum of Art of Georgia]. Juvelirnoe iskusstvo i material'naja kul'tura: Sbornik statej [Jewelry and Material Culture: Collected Articles]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Publ, 2001, pp. 218–233. (In Russian).
  26. Bilvina O.L. Proizvedeniya antichnosti v kollektsii M.P. Botkina [Antiquity works in the collection of M.P. Botkin]. Trudy Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskaja konferencija “Rerihovskoe nasledie” [Proceedings of the International Scientific and Practical Conference “Roerich Heritage”]. Vol. 2. St. Petersburg, Irida-pros Publ., 2005, pp. 228–240. (In Russian).
  27. Birbaum F. Ostatki vizantijskogo iskusstva ili talantlivye poddelki [Remnants of Byzantine art or talented forgeries]. Skurlov V.V., Faberzhe T.F., Kvashnin S.I., Perevyshko A.I. Franc Birbaum. Glavnyj master firmy Faberzhe [Franz Bierbaum. Chief Master of the Faberge firm]. St. Petersburg, Faberge Memorial Fund , 2016, pp. 114–116. (In Russian).
  28. Bobrinskij A.A. Narodnye russkie derevjannye izdelija: predmety domashnego, hozjajstvennogo i otchasti cerkovnogo obihoda [Folk Russian wooden products: household, household and partly church items]. Issue 8, 1912, 6 p., 15 l. (In Russian).
  29. Bukina A.G. Korinfskie vazy i ih antichnye imitacii. Katalog kollekcii [Corinthian vases and their antique imitations. Collection catalog]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2015. 454 p. (In Russian).
  30. Bukina A.G. O sisteme rospisi korinfskogo kratera iz kollekcii M.P. Botkina [About the painting system of the Corinthian crater from the collection of M.P. Botkin]. Soobshhenija Gosudarstvennogo Jermitazha [State Hermitage Messages]. 2004, Issue 62, pp.80–85. (In Russian).
  31. Buryshkin P.A. Moskva kupecheskaja [Moscow merchant]. Moscow, Stolica Publ., 1990. 349 p. (In Russian).
  32. Vazhinskaja I.N. Pamjatniki melkoj cerkovnoj plastiki Afona iz kollekcii M.P. Botkina v sobranii Russkogo muzeja [Monuments of small church sculpture of Athos from the collection of M.P. Botkin in the collection of the Russian Museum]. Stranicy istorii otechestvennogo iskusstva. Sbornik statej po materialam nauchnoj konferencii [Pages of the history of Russian art. Collection of articles based on the materials of the scientific conference]. Issue 26. St. Petersburg, Palace Editions Publ., 2015, pp. 107–114. (In Russian).
  33. Vesti otovsjudu [News from everywhere]. Zolotoe runo — The Golden Fleece,1907, No. 10, p. 84. (In Russian).
  34. Vizantijskie drevnosti: Proizvedenija iskusstva IV–XV vekov v sobranii Muzeev Moskovskogo Kremlja: katalog [Byzantine Antiquities: Works of Art of the 4th – 15th centuries in the Collection of the Moscow Kremlin Museums: catalog]. Moscow, Pinakoteka Publ., 2013. 607 p. (In Russian).
  35. Vnutrennie izvestija. V Imperatorskoj Arheologicheskoj komissii [Internal news. At the Imperial Archaeological Commission]. Pravitel'stvennyj vestnik — Government Gazette, 1902, 6 April, No. 78, p. 3. (In Russian).
  36. Vostochnoe serebro. Atlas drevnej serebrjanoj i zolotoj posudy vostochnogo proishozhdenija, najdennoj preimushhestvenno v predelah Rossijskoj Imperii [Eastern Silver. Atlas of ancient silver and gold dishes of oriental origin, found mainly within the Russian Empire]. St. Petersburg, Imperatorskaja Arheologicheskaja komissija, 1909. 18 p., 131 l. (In Russian).
  37. Vystavka risunkov i jestampov v Akademii hudozhestv [Exhibition of drawings and prints at the Academy of Arts]. Zolotoe Runo — The Golden Fleece, 1908, No. 1, p. 84. (In Russian).
  38. Vystavka risunkov i jestampov. Janvar' 1908, S.-Peterburg [Exhibition of drawings and prints. January 1908, St. Petersburg]. St. Petersburg, [1908]. 43 p. (In Russian).
  39. Gorbunova K.S. Chernofigurnye atticheskie vazy v Jermitazhe: Katalog [Black-figure attic vases in the Hermitage: Catalog]. Leningrad, Iskusstvo Publ., 1983. 223 p. (In Russian).
  40. Allenova O.A. et al. (comp.). Gosudarstvennaja Tret'jakovskaja galereja. Zhivopis' pervoj poloviny XIX veka: katalog [State Tretyakov Gallery. Painting of the first half of the 19th century: catalog]. Moscow, SKANRUS Publ., 2005. 482 p. (In Russian).
  41. Antonova A.Z. et al. (comp.). Gosudarstvennaja Tret'jakovskaja galereja. Risunok XIX veka: katalog [State Tretyakov Gallery. Drawings of the 19th century: catalog]. Moscow, Skanrus Publ., 2013. Vol. 2, book 2. 461 p. (In Russian).
  42. Guseva E.K. et al. (comp.). Gosudarstvennaja Tret'jakovskaja galereja: katalog sobranija [State Tretyakov Gallery: collection catalog]. Moscow, Krasnaja ploshhad' Publ., 1995. Vol. I: Old Russian art of the 10th – early 15th century]. 270 p. (In Russian).
  43. Gosudarstvennyj arhiv Rossijskoj Federacii [State Archives of the Russian Federation], coll. R-5777, aids 1, fol. 114. (In Russian).
  44. Grecheskie terrakoty IV v. do R.X. iz sobranija M.P. Botkina [Greek terracotta 4th century. B.C. from the collection of M.P. Botkin]. Hudozhestvennye sokrovishha Rossii — Artistic treasures of Russia, 1904, No. 10. p. 353. (In Russian).
  45. Guseva E.N. M.P. Botkin — kollektsioner proizvedenii A.A. Ivanova i izdatel' ego pisem [M.P. Botkin is a collector of A.A. Ivanov and the publisher of his letters]. Kollekcionery i mecenaty Rossii. Materialy nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii [Collectors and patrons of the arts of Russia. Proceedings of Conference]. Samara, Samara Art Museum, 1998, pp. 169–179. (In Russian).
  46. D. Ja. Nekrolog. M.P. Botkin [Obituary. M.P. Botkin]. Moskovskie vedomosti — Moskovskie vedomosti, 1914, January 26, No. 21, p. 4. (In Russian).
  47. Zhivopisnoe obozrenie — Picturesque Review, 1898, No. 27, p. 512. (In Russian).
  48. Ivanova O.K. Istoricheskie istochniki o kollekcionerskoj dejatel'nosti M.P. Botkina [Historical sources on M.P. Botkin’s collecting activities]. Pavel Tret'jakov. Predshestvenniki i posledovateli: chastnoe i muzejnoe kollekcionirovanie XVIII – nachala XX veka [Pavel Tretyakov. Predecessors and followers: private and museum collecting of the 18th – early 20th centuries. Proceedings of Conference]. Moscow, State Tretyakov Gallery, 2014, pp. 154–165. (In Russian).
  49. Izvestija Imperatorskoj arheologicheskoj komissii [News of the Imperial Archaeological Commission]. 1902, vol. 3, Application, p. 13. (In Russian).
  50. Illjustrirovannyj katalog Hudozhestvennogo otdela Vserossijskoj vystavki v Moskve, 1882 g. [Illustrated catalog of the Art Department of the All-Russian Exhibition in Moscow, 1882]. St. Petersburg, 1882. XVI, 82, XVI p., 88 l. (In Russian).
  51. Bank A.V., Bessonova M.A. (comp.). Iskusstvo Vizantii v sobranijah SSSR: Katalog vystavki [Art of Byzantium in the collections of the USSR: Exhibition catalog]. Moscow, Sovetskiy hudozhnik Publ., 1977, vol. 2. 155 p. (In Russian).
  52. Bank A.V., Bessonova M.A. (comp.). Iskusstvo Vizantii v sobranijah SSSR: Katalog vystavki [Art of Byzantium in the collections of the USSR: Exhibition catalog]. Moscow, Sovetskiy hudozhnik Publ., 1977, vol. 3. 179 p. (In Russian).
  53. Katalog Vystavki izobrazhenij bogomateri [Catalog of the Exhibition of Images of the Mother of God]. Moscow, A.I. Mamontov Publ., 1897. 83 p. (In Russian).
  54. Katalog Kartinnoj galerei. Moskovskij publichnyj i Rumjancevskij muzej [Catalog of the Art Gallery. Moscow Public and Rumyantsev Museum]. Moscow, S. n., 1908. 139 p. (In Russian).
  55. Katalog Muzeja Imperatorskogo Obshhestva Pooshhrenija Hudozhestv [Catalog of the Museum of the Imperial Society for the Encouragement of Arts]. St. Petersburg, S. n., 1904. 449 p. (In Russian).
  56. Kizerickij G.E. Antichnye maski iz sobranija M.P. Botkina [Antique masks from the collection of M.P. Botkin]. Hudozhestvennye sokrovishha Rossii — Artistic treasures of Russia, 1901, vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 11–18. (In Russian).
  57. Nekrasova-Shhedrinskaja E.N. et al. (comp.). Kozha. Hudozhestvennye izdelija staroj Evropy: katalog vystavki [Leather. Artworks from old Europe: exhibition catalog]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2019. 343 p. (In Russian).
  58. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M., Verhovskaya I.B. (comp.). Kollekcii Mihaila i Sergeja Botkinyh: katalog [Collections of Mikhail and Sergei Botkin: catalog]. St. Petersburg, Palace Editions Publ., 2011. 212 p. (In Russian).
  59. Kondakov N. P. Istorija i pamjatniki Vizantijskoj jemali [History and monuments of Byzantine enamel]. St. Petersburg, A. Zvenigorodskoy Publ., 1892. VIII, 395 p. (In Russian).
  60. Peredolskaya A.A. (comp.), Gorbunova K.S. (ed.). Krasnofigurnye atticheskie vazy v Jermitazhe: katalog [Red-figure attic vases in the Hermitage: catalog]. Leningrad, Sovetskiy hudozhnik, 1967. 404 p. (In Russian).
  61. Kryzhanovskaya M.Ya. Zapadnoevropejskaja reznaja kost' Srednih vekov [Western European medieval ivories: katalog kollekcii]. ]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2014. 310 p. (In Russian).
  62. Kube A.N. Ital'janskaja majolika XV – XVIII vekov. Sobranie Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha [Italian majolica of the 15th – 18th centuries. Collection of the State Hermitage]. Moscow, Iskusstvo Publ., 1976. 60 p., 109 l. (In Russian).
  63. Kustodieva T.K. Ital'janskaja zhivopis' XIII–XVI vekov [Italian painting 13th –16th centuries. Collection catalog]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2011. 445 p. (In Russian).
  64. Kustodieva T.K. Triptih iz sobraniya M.P. Botkina v kollekcii Jermitazha [Triptych from the collection of M.P. Botkin in the Hermitage collection]. Soobshhenija Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha [State Hermitage Messages]. Issue 63. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2005, pp. 5–9. (In Russian).
  65. Lazarevskiy I.I. Muzej M.P. Botkina [Museum of M.P. Botkin]. Izvestija Imperatorskoj Arheologicheskoj komissii [News of the Imperial Archaeological Commission]. 1913, vol. 48, Application, pp. 67–70. (In Russian).
  66. Literaturnyj muzej Instituta russkoj literatury RAN. Sobranie drevnostej M.P. Botkina [Literary Museum of the Institute of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Collection of antiquities M.P. Botkin]. Photo album. 48 l. (In Russian).
  67. M.P. Botkin [M.P. Botkin]. Niva, 1914, No. 9, pp. 175–176. (In Russian).
  68. Ivanova E.N. (comp.). Majolika Urbino XVI – XVII vekov: katalog kollekcii Gosudarstvennyj Jermitazh [Urbino Maiolica 16th – 17th centuries: collection catalog of the State Hermitage]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2019. 266 p. (In Russian).
  69. Maculevich L.A. Vizantijskie reznye kosti sobranija M.P. Botkina (Gosudarstvennyj Jermitazh) [Byzantine carved bones from the collection of M.P. Botkin (State Hermitage Museum)]. Sbornik Gosudarstvennogo Jermitazha [Collection of the State Hermitage]. Petrograd, 1923, vol. 2, pp. 3–72. (In Russian).
  70. Mir iskusstva [The world of art.]. 1904, vol. 11, No. 2, p. 52. (In Russian).
  71. Na kraju ojkumeny. Greki i varvary na severnom beregu Ponta Jevksinskogo. Katalog vystavki iz fondov GIM [On the edge of the ecumene. Greeks and barbarians on the northern bank of the Pontus Euxine. Exhibition catalog from the SHM funds]. Moscow, S. n., 2002. 141 p. (In Russian).
  72. Nekrasova E. N. Lazur' i zoloto Limozha [Azure and gold of Limoges]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2009. 182 p. (In Russian).
  73. Nekrolog. M.P. Botkin [Obituary. M.P. Botkin]. Sankt-Peterburgskie Vedomosti — Saint Petersburg Vedomosti, 1914, January 24, No. 19. (In Russian).
  74. Neradovskiy P.I. Akvareli i risunki A.A. Ivanova (po materialam Gosudarstvennogo Russkogo Muzeja) [Watercolors and drawings by A.A. Ivanova (based on materials from the State Russian Museum)]. Hudozhestvennyj otdel Russkogo Muzeja. Materialy po russkomu iskusstvu [Art department of the Russian Museum. Materials on Russian art]. Leningrad, S. n., 1928, pp. 234–254. (In Russian).
  75. Neradovskiy P. I. Iz zhizni hudozhnika [From the artist's life]. Leningrad, Hudozhnik Publ., 1965. 198 p. (In Russian).
  76. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Drevnerusskoe prikladnoe iskusstvo iz kollekcii M.P. Botkina v sobranii Russkogo muzeya [Old Russian applied art from the collection of M.P. Botkin in the collection of the Russian Museum]. Kollekcii i kollekcionery. Sbornik statej po materialam nauchnoj konferencii [Collections and collectors. Proceedings of conference]. St. Petersburg, Palace Editions Publ., 2009, pp. 39–54. (In Russian).
  77. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Zarubezhnye drevnosti iz sobraniya M.P. Botkina v kollekcii Russkogo muzeya [Foreign antiquities from the collection of M.P. Botkin in the collection of the Russian Museum]. Stranicy istorii otechestvennogo iskusstva. Sbornik statej po materialam nauchnoj konferencii [Pages of the history of Russian art. Proceedings of conference]. Issue 18. St. Petersburg, Palace Editions Publ., 2010, pp.7–27. (In Russian).
  78. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Mihail Petrovich Botkin — chelovek i kollekcioner [Mikhail Petrovich Botkin — a man and a collector]. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M., Verhovskaya I.B. (comp.). Kollekcii Mihaila i Sergeja Botkinyh: katalog [Collections of Mikhail and Sergei Botkin: catalog]. St. Petersburg, Palace Editions Publ., 2011, pp. 9–21. (In Russian).
  79. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. M.P. Botkin i ego kollektsiya [M.P. Botkin and his collection ]. Istoricheskie Botkinskie chteniya. Vyp. 1 [Historical Botkin Readings. Issue 1]. St. Petersburg, Saint-Petersburg State Roerich Family Museum, 2017, pp. 24–37. (In Russian).
  80. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Pamjatnik ukrainskoj rez'by iz kollekcii Mihaila Petrovicha Botkina [Monument of Ukrainian carving from the collection of Mikhail Petrovich Botkin]. Istoricheskie Botkinskie chtenija. Vyp. 2 [Historical Botkin Readings. Issue 2]. St. Petersburg, Saint-Petersburg State Roerich Family Museum, 2019, pp. 54–66. (In Russian).
  81. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Pamjatniki drevnerusskogo prikladnogo iskusstva v sobranii M.P. Botkina [Monuments of ancient Russian applied art in the collection of M.P. Botkin]. Sud'by muzejnyh kollekcij: Materialy VII Carskosel'skoj nauchnoj konferencii [The fate of museum collections. Proceedings of conference]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2001, pp. 137–145. (In Russian).
  82. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Proizvedenija vizantijskogo prikladnogo iskusstva v kollekcii Russkogo muzeja [Works of Byzantine applied art in the collection of the Russian Museum]. Trudy Gosudarstvennogo Jermitazha. T. 69: Vizantija v kontekste mirovoj kul'tury: sbornik nauchnyh trudov, posvjashhennyj pamjati Alisy Vladimirovny Bank (1906–1984) [Works of the State Hermitage. Vol. 69: Byzantium in the context of world culture: a collection of scientific works dedicated to the memory of Alisa Vladimirovna Bank (1906–1984)]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2013, pp. 156–192. (In Russian).
  83. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Rannehristianskie i rannevizantijskie ukrashenija iz sobranija M.P. Botkina v kollekcii Russkogo muzeja i ih simvolika [Early Christian and early Byzantine jewelry from the collection of M.P. Botkin in the collection of the Russian Museum and their symbols]. Istoricheskie Botkinskie chtenija. Vyp. 3 [Historical Botkin Readings. Issue 3]. St. Petersburg, Saint-Petersburg State Roerich Family Museum, 2020, pp. 41–58. (In Russian).
  84. Novakovskaya-Buhman S.M. Ukrashenija iz razroznennyh drevnerusskih kladov v sobranii M.P. Botkina [Jewelry from scattered Old Russian treasures in the collection of M.P. Botkin]. Slavjano-russkoe juvelirnoe delo i ego istoki. Materialy Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii [Slavic and old Russian art of jewelry and its roots. Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference]. St. Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriya Publ., 2010, pp. 221–244. (In Russian).
  85. Novoe vremja. Illjustrirovannoe prilozhenie [New time. Illustrated application]. 1913, September 14 (27), No. 13473, p. 7. (In Russian).
  86. Ovsjannikova S.A. Chastnoe sobiratel'stvo v Rossii v poreformennuju jepohu (1861–1917 gg.) [Private collecting in Russia in the post-reform era (1861–1917)]. Ocherki istorii muzejnogo dela v Rossii [Essays on the history of museum work in Russia]. Issue 2. Moscow, 1960, pp. 66–144. (In Russian).
  87. Opis' predmetam iskusstva, priobretennym Hudozhestvenno-promyshlennym muzeumom, uchrezhdennym vysochajshe utverzhdennom Obshhestvom pooshhrenija hudozhnikov, v 1873 godu [Inventory of art objects acquired by the Museum of Art and Industry, established by the highest approved by the Society for the Encouragement of Artists, in 1873]. St. Petersburg, S. n., 1874. 159 p. (In Russian).
  88. Otdel pis'mennyh istochnikov Gosudarstvennogo istoricheskogo muzeja [Department of written sources of the State Historical Museum], coll. 122, No. 181. (In Russian).
  89. Otchjot Imperatorskogo Rossijskogo istoricheskogo muzeja imeni imperatora Aleksandra III v Moskve za 1883–1908 gody [Report of the Imperial Russian Historical Museum named after Emperor Alexander the Third in Moscow for 1883–1908]. Moscow, Synod Publ., 1916. 208 p. (In Russian).
  90. Otchjot imperatorskoj publichnoj biblioteki za 1877 god [Report of the Imperial Public Library for 1877]. St. Petersburg, S. n., 1879. 213 p. (In Russian).
  91. Otchjot Moskovskogo Publichnogo i Rumjancevskogo muzeev do 1 janvarja 1864 goda [Report of the Moscow Public and Rumyantsev museums before January 1, 1864]. Moscow, S. n., 1864. 178 p. (In Russian).
  92. Peredol'skaja A. Pozdnekrasnofigurnyj kilik iz sobranija M.P. Botkina [Late red-figured kilik from the collection of M.P. Botkin]. Soobshhenija Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha — State Hermitage Messages, 1963, Issue 24, pp. 33–35. (In Russian).
  93. Pivovarova N.V. Pamjatniki cerkovnoj stariny v Peterburge-Petrograde-Leningrade. Iz istorii formirovanija muzejnyh kollekcij: 1850–1930-e gody [Monuments of church antiquity in St. Petersburg-Petrograd-Leningrad. From the history of the formation of museum collections: 1850–1930s]. Moscow, BuksMart Publ., 2014. 432 p. (In Russian).
  94. Polovcov A.V. Fedor Antonovich Bruni: Biograficheskij ocherk [Fyodor Antonovich Bruni: Biographical sketch]. St. Petersburg, Academy of Arts Publ., 1907, 162 p. 48 l. (In Russian).
  95. Polunina N., Frolov A. Kollekcionery staroj Moskvy [Collectors of old Moscow.]. Moscow, Nezavisimaja gazeta Publ., 1997. 526 p. (In Russian).
  96. Pyatnickiy Yu. O proishozhdenii nekotoryh peregorodchatyh vizantiyskih emaley iz kollekcii Ehrmitazha [About the origin of some cloisonn? Byzantine enamels from the Hermitage collection]. Ehrmitazhnye chtenija pamjati B.B. Piotrovskogo. Tezisy dokladov [Hermitage readings in memory of B.B. Piotrovsky. Abstracts]. St. Petersburg, S. n., 2010, pp. 41–45. (In Russian).
  97. Rappe T.V. Shedevry evropejskoj mebeli XV – nachala XX veka v sobranii Jermitazha: al'bom [Masterpieces of European furniture of the 15th – early 20th centuries in the Hermitage collection: an album.]. St. Petersburg, State Hermitage, 2016. 471 p. (In Russian).
  98. Rerih N.K. Listy dnevnika [Diary sheets]. Moscow, International Center of the Roerichs, 1995, vol. 2. 511 p. (In Russian).
  99. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva [Russian State Archives of Literature and Art], coll. 167, aids 1, item 7. (In Russian).
  100. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva [Russian State Archives of Literature and Art], coll. 191, aids 1, item 1278. (In Russian).
  101. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva [Russian State Archives of Literature and Art], coll. 1932, aids 1, item 63. (In Russian).
  102. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva [Russian State Archives of Literature and Art], coll. 1932, aids 1, item 127. (In Russian).
  103. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva [Russian State Archives of Literature and Art], coll. 815, aids 1, item 24. (In Russian).
  104. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva [Russian State Archives of Literature and Art], coll. 822, aids 1, item 258. (In Russian).
  105. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva [Russian State Archives of Literature and Art], coll. 904, aids 1, item 27. (In Russian).
  106. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj istoricheskij arhiv [Russian State Historical Archive], coll. 472, aids 50, fol. 1663. (In Russian).
  107. Rukopisnyj otdel Instituta istorii russkoj literatury Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Manuscript Department of the Institute of the History of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences], coll. 365, aids 1, No. 2. (In Russian).
  108. Rukopisnyj otdel Instituta istorii russkoj literatury Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Manuscript Department of the Institute of the History of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences], coll. 365, aids 1, No. 45. (In Russian).
  109. Rukopisnyj otdel Instituta istorii russkoj literatury Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Manuscript Department of the Institute of the History of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences], coll. 365, aids 1, No. 47. (In Russian).
  110. Rukopisnyj otdel Instituta istorii russkoj literatury Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Manuscript Department of the Institute of the History of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences], coll. 365, aids 1, No. 48. (In Russian).
  111. Rukopisnyj otdel Instituta istorii russkoj literatury Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Manuscript Department of the Institute of the History of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences], coll. 365, aids 1, No. 50. (In Russian).
  112. Rukopisnyj otdel Instituta istorii russkoj literatury Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Manuscript Department of the Institute of the History of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences], coll. 365, aids 1, No.146. (In Russian).
  113. Rukopisnyj otdel Instituta istorii russkoj literatury Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Manuscript Department of the Institute of the History of Russian Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences], coll. 365, aids 1, No.147. (In Russian).
  114. Russkiy muzej imperatora Aleksandra III [Russian Museum of Emperor Alexander the Third]. Zolotoe Runo — The Golden Fleece, 1907, No. 10, p. 73. (In Russian).
  115. Ryumin A.A. Na ostrove vospominaniy [On the island of memories]. Nashe nasledie — Our heritage, 1991, No. 5, pp. 147–154. (In Russian).
  116. Sankt-Peterburgskij gosudarstvennyj muzej-institut sem'i Rerihov [St. Petersburg State Roerich Museum and Institute]. KP-8457. Ohrannoe udostoverenie s podpis'ju narodnogo komissara po zavedovaniju dvorcami i muzejami respubliki A. V. Lunacharskogo [Security certificate signed by the people's commissar for the management of palaces and museums of the republic A.V. Lunacharsky]. Petrograd, 16.02.1918. (In Russian).
  117. Simakov N. Russkij ornament v starinnyh obrazcah hudozhestvenno-promyshlennogo proizvodstva [Russian ornament in old samples of art and industrial production]. St. Petersburg, Obshestvo pooshhrenija hudozhnikov Publ., 1882. 6 p., 24 l. (In Russian).
  118. Sobranie M.P. Botkina [Collection of M.P. Botkin]. St. Petersburg, Tovarishhestvo R. Golike i A. Vil'borg, 1911. 38 p., 103 il. (In Russian).
  119. Stasov V.V. Pavel Mihajlovich Tret'jakov i ego kartinnaja galereja [Pavel Mikhailovich Tretyakov and his picture gallery]. Russkaja starina — Russian antiquity, 1893, No. 12, pp. 569–608. (In Russian).
  120. Stasov V.V. Sobranie sochinenij v 4-h tomah [Collected works in 4 volumes.]. St. Petersburg, M.M. Stasyulevich Publ., 1894, vol. 2, XVI, 1050 columns, 6 p., 484 columns. (In Russian).
  121. Stepanova S.S. Delovoj chelovek Mihail Botkin. K istorii tvorcheskogo nasledija A.A. Ivanova [Business man Mikhail Botkin. To the history of A.A. Ivanov]. Mir muzeja — Museum world, 2006, No. 7, pp. 30–36. (In Russian).
  122. Stolbova E.I. Zhivopisnye proizvedenija A.A. Ivanova iz kollekcii M.P. Botkina v sobranii Russkogo muzeja [The paintings by A.A. Ivanov from the collection of M.P. Botkin in the collection of the Russian Museum]. Kollekcii i kollekcionery. Sbornik statej po materialam nauchnoj konferencii [Collections and collectors. Proceedings of conference]. St. Petersburg, Palace Editions Publ., 2009, pp. 90–103. (In Russian).
  123. Turaev B.A. Opisanie egipetskih pamjatnikov v russkih muzejah i sobranijah [Description of Egyptian monuments in Russian museums and collections]. St. Petersburg, Academy of Sciences, [1899], pp. 115–164. (In Russian).
  124. Uvarova N.I. Istorija postuplenija grafiki A.A. Ivanova iz kollekcii M.P. Botkina v Russkij muzej [History of receipt of graphics by A.A. Ivanov from the collection of M.P. Botkin to the Russian Museum]. Sud'by muzejnyh kollekcij. Materialy VI Carskosel'skoj nauchnoj konferencii [The fate of museum collections. Proceedings of conference]. St. Petersburg, S. n., 2000, pp. 243–252. (In Russian).
  125. Uvarova N.I. Grafika Aleksandra Ivanova iz kollekcii Mihaila Botkina [Graphics by Alexander Ivanov from the collection of Mikhail Botkin]. N.K. Rerih i ego sovremenniki. Kollekcii i kollekcionery: Sbornik statej po materialam mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii [N.K. Roerich and his contemporaries. Collections and collectors. Proceedings of conference]. Odessa, S. n., 2001, pp.73–79. (In Russian).
  126. Hanutina Z.V. Predmety antichnogo fonda GMIR iz chastnyh sobranij XIX – nachala XX vv. [Things of the antique fund of the State Museum of History from private collections of the 19th – early 20th centuries]. Trudy Gosudarstvennogo muzeja istorii religii — Proceedings of the State Museum of the History of Religion, 2018, No. 18, pp. 39–47. (In Russian).
  127. Huskivadze L.Z. Srednevekovye peregorodchatye jemali iz sobranija Gosudarstvennogo muzeja iskusstv Gruzii [Medieval cloisonn? enamels from the collection of the State Museum of Art of Georgia]. Tbilisi, S. n., 1984, 160 p. (In Russian).
  128. Central'nyj gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva Sankt-Peterburga [Central State Archive of Literature and Art of St. Petersburg], coll. R-32, aids 1, foll. 13. (In Russian).
  129. Central'nyj gosudarstvennyj arhiv literatury i iskusstva Sankt-Peterburga [Central State Archive of Literature and Art of St. Petersburg], coll. R-36, aids 1, foll. 44. (In Russian).
  130. Central'nyj gosudarstvennyj istoricheskij arhiv Sankt-Peterburga [Central State Historical Archive of St. Petersburg], coll. 448, aids 1, foll. 1716. (In Russian).
  131. Central'nyj gosudarstvennyj istoricheskij arhiv Sankt-Peterburga [Central State Historical Archive of St. Petersburg], coll. 448, aids 1, foll.1809. (In Russian).
  132. Chuvaeva Yu. D. Sobiratel'skaja dejatel'nost' M.P. Botkina (Formirovanie kollekcii prikladnogo iskusstva ital'janskogo Vozrozhdenija) [Gathering activity of M.P. Botkin (Formation of the collection of applied art of the Italian Renaissance)]. Nasledie — sovremennost': sbornik materialov nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencij [Heritage — modernity. Proceedings of conference]. Samara, Ofort Publ., 2009, pp. 206–216. (In Russian).
  133. Chuyko V. M.P. Botkin [M.P. Botkin]. Enciklopedicheskij slovar' [Encyclopedic Dictionary]. St. Petersburg, S. n., 1891. Vol. 4 a, p. 499. (In Russian).
  134. Shebuev N. Pamjati M.P. Botkina [In memory of M.P. Botkin]. Solnce Rossii. Zhurnal literatury i iskusstva — The sun of Russia. Literature and Art Journal, 1914, No. 16, pp. 2–3. (In Russian)/
  135. Shchukin P.I. Vospominanija. Iz istorii mecenatstva Rossii [Memories. From the history of patronage of Russia]. Moscow, State Historical Museum, 1997. 320 p. (In Russian).
  136. Achechova A. Les ?maux “byzantins” de la collection de M.P. Botkine (1839–1914): Aspects du collectionnisme des objects d’art a la fin du XIXe et au debut du XXe si?cle. These. Paris, 2012. 274 p.
  137. Actes du douzi?me Congr?s international des orientalistes. Rome, 1899 , T. 1. 228 p.
  138. Addressbuch der Museen, Bibliotheken, Sammler und Antiquare Ein Handbuch f?r Sammler, Auctionatoren, MuseumsVorst?nde und H?ndler. 1897. 380 s.
  139. Almagro Gorbea M. Un ?nfora ?tica de la 'Botkin Class' en Huelva y la fecha final del emporion focense Madrider Mitteilungen. 2018, Vol. 59, pp. 298–313.
  140. Art collection of the late Mrs Henry Walters: vente du 30 novembre au 4 d?cembre 1943. 1943, 255 p.
  141. Beazley J. D. Attic Black-Figure Vase-Painters. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1956. XVI, 852 p.
  142. Berenson D. The central italian painters of the Renaissance. New York, London: G.P. Putham’s sons, 1909. 308 p.
  143. Bode W. Denkma?ler der Renaissance-Sculptur Toscanas in historischer Anordnung. M?nchen, 1892. 250 tab.
  144. Buckton D. Bogus Byzantine Enamels in Baltimore and Washington, D.C. The Journal of the Walters Art Gallery. 1988, vol. 46, pp. 11–24.
  145. Buckton D. Byzantine enamels in the twentieth century Byzantine Style, Religion and Civilization. In Honour of Sir Steven Runciman. Cambridge, 2006, pp. 25–90.
  146. Catalogue des objets d'art, antiques du moyen-a?ge et de la renaissance dependant de la succession Alessandro Castellani et dont la vente aura lieu a? Rome, 17 Mars–10 avril 1884. Paris, 1884. 83, 83 p.
  147. Colletion M.-P. Botkine. Saint-Petersbourg, Leipzig: K.-W. Hiersemann, 1914. 38 s., 103 ill.
  148. Craig P. C., Aikens B. D., Ashley S. L., Fernandez R. M. Jacques Seligmann & Co. A finding aid to the Jacques Seligmann & Co. Records (bulk 1913–1974). Archives of American Ary, 2001, October, pp. 1–8.
  149. Demaison M. Une exposition retrospective a Saint-Petersbourg. Les Arts; revue mensuelle des muse?es, collections, expositions, 1908, decemre, № 84, р. 3.
  150. Lehmbeck L. (ed.). Gifts of European Art from The Ahmanson Foundation. Vol. 1: Italian Painting and Sculpture. Los Angeles, 2019, 167 p.
  151. Helfenstein E., Eremin K., Newman R., Gates G. Drayman-Weisser T., DeRoo C.S., Klausmeyer P., Freestone I. Technical examination of enamels from the Botkin collection. The International Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works, 2012, pp. 147–156.
  152. Maskell A. Russian art and art objects in Russia. A handbook to the reproductions of goldsmiths' work and other art treasures from that country in the South Kensington Museum. London, Pub. for the Committee of Council, 1884, 278 p.
  153. Metallic reproduction of foreign art. Bulletin of the Metropolitan museum of art, 1906, April, vol. 1, No. 5, p. 69.
  154. Metropolitan Museum of Art. Fourteenth annual report of the Trustees of the Association: 1883 of the Trustees of the Association (1884). New York, 1884, 28 p.
  155. Mommsen H. Corpus Vasorum Antiquorum. Germany 94. Berlin 14: Attisch schwarzfigurige Amphoren. Munich, 2013. 138 s.
  156. Paintings in the Cleveland Museum of Art. 1952, 63 p.
  157. Peredolski A. Verschollene rotfigurige. Vasen Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archaelogischen Instiruts, Romische Abteilung, 1927, XLII.
  158. R?au L. Saint-P?tersbourg. Ouvrage illustr? de 150 gravures. Paris, 1913, 49 p.
  159. Reinach S. Re?pertoire de reliefs grecs et romains. T. 3. Italie – Suisse. Paris, 1912, 566 p.
  160. Renart E. Suppl?ment aux r?pertoires des collectionneurs et aux listes d'amateurs ?trangers publi?s depuis 1893. Paris, 1912, 366 p.
  161. Schlie F. Vaso della cirenaica. Annali de’ll instituto de Rome, 1868, pp.320–330, Pl. L.M.
  162. Schulz J. Der Byzantinische Zellenschmelz. Frankfurt, 1890, 104 p., ill.
  163. Selling Russia's treasures: the Soviet trade in nationalized art, 1917–1938. New York, 2013. 362 p.
  164. Siple E. S. Byzantine Enamels in Detroit, Worcester and Boston. The Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs, 1928, October, vol. 53, No. 307, pp.197–199.
  165. Sobranie M[onsieur].M. Botkina. [La collection M.M. Botkine]. Saint-Petersbourg, 1914. 38 p., 103 ill.
  166. Vereneule С. Greek and Roman Sculpture in America. Bostоn, 1981. 406 p.
  167. Wegen Umbau der Villa, freiwillige Versteigerung einer kompletten Villeneinrichtung in Wien, XIX., Hohe Warte 46 (Haltestelle Stra?enbahn G2)…1 und 2. Oktober 1937. Wien, 1937. 31 s.